Cold Shoulder

So a girlfriend and I were discussing this sharp shouldered fall trend last night, and just can't decide how we feel about it. It gets dreadfully close to crossing the line back in to 80's-shoulder-pad-hell, while at the same time is rather striking. On a tiny frame, it seems to be adorable, but I'm just not sure how it might look on normal human sized people. What do you guys think? Sharp or dull?