St. John Cream Skirt vs. St. John Blue Skirt

SJCream

Size: 2
Waist: 24"
Length: 21"

Buy It Now/Make Offer: $59
S&H: $6.95

SJBlue
Size: 2
Waist: 24"
Hips: 34"
Length: 20"

Starting Bid: $0.99, 1 Bid
S&H: $6
Ends: November 9, 2010; 3:00PM EST (6:00PM PST)

Always felt SJ was old lady, stuffy, and oftentimes borderline tacky, all the while exemplifying luxury, which makes me determined to have an SJ piece which is none of the prior.  I need my clothing to help me fake class, heheh.  I like SJC; it looks more/better fitted, but prob wouldn't offer more than $30, if even that.  Might be too light, too.  Added SJB because I need bolder colors, but would prob mismatch, even with solids.  Starting bid was so low, though, I had to watch -- max at $20?  Which do you prefer?

A -- 11/6/10: Agree re:oldlady, etc.  Even Angelina Jolie's ads couldn't pull the brand out of witheredsocialite in my mind.  I prefer the SJC too, like the color better, and also the fittedness.  Weird flare/A-line shape of SJB seems like it would not look so good on.  Would offer $40 on SJC max, pass on SJB.

T, 11/9/10: Wow, SJB ended at $1.79, 3 bids.  LOL, what a steal.

T, 11/13/13: SJC seller changed it to 30% off, buy it now or best offer.  Sold for $35.